How to Be a High School Superstar: Why It Still Matters

Home » Blog » How to Be a High School Superstar: Why It Still Matters
smiling-student-with-curly-hair-writing-on-notebook

In an era of expensive summer programs, packaged research opportunities, and resume-building activities, the best way to stand out in college admissions may be to do less and pursue what genuinely interests you.

In 2010, Cal Newport published How to Be a High School Superstar: A Revolutionary Plan to Get into College by Standing Out (Without Burning Out). More than 15 years later, we believe his advice is more relevant than ever.

In fact, How to Be a High School Superstar is one of the books we recommend that both students and their parents read when they first begin working with Great College Advice. We believe it helps establish the right mindset early in the college planning process. Rather than approaching high school as a four-year exercise in resume building, we encourage families to view these years as an opportunity for exploration, personal growth, and the development of genuine interests. Newport’s message also helps parents understand why giving their children the freedom to pursue their own passions can be far more valuable than constantly adding another activity to their schedules.

At Great College Advice, we have long embraced Newport’s central philosophy: The most compelling college applicants aren’t necessarily the busiest students. They’re the ones who develop genuine interests, take initiative, and accomplish something meaningful.

Unfortunately, today’s college admissions environment often encourages exactly the opposite behavior.

The Rise of Pay-to-Play College Admissions

Over the past decade, an entire industry has emerged around helping high school students build impressive-looking resumes. Families spend thousands of dollars on prestigious-sounding summer programs, research mentorships, international service trips, and opportunities to launch nonprofits.

Some of these experiences are genuinely valuable. But others are little more than expensive credentials designed to strengthen a college application.

Experienced admissions officers understand the difference between authentic engagement and activities that appear manufactured for admissions purposes. A student who participates in a costly research program isn’t necessarily more impressive than one who independently pursues an intellectual curiosity. In fact, admissions officers will be much more impressed by an endeavor that is organically curated.

The question isn’t simply what a student accomplished. It’s what motivated the student, how much initiative they demonstrated, and what they learned along the way.

This distinction lies at the heart of Newport’s philosophy.

Three Lessons from How to Be a High School Superstar

Newport introduces three principles that challenge conventional thinking about extracurricular activities and college admissions.

1. The Law of Underscheduling: Leave Room for Exploration

Many ambitious high school students have virtually no free time. Between academics, athletics, clubs, volunteering, and test preparation, every weeknight and weekend is full.

Newport argues that this approach can be counterproductive.

Students need unstructured time to explore interests, experiment with ideas, and discover what genuinely excites them. An overscheduled student may never have the opportunity to pursue an unexpected curiosity.

Free time isn’t wasted time. It’s often where creativity and meaningful personal development begin.

Parents should resist the temptation to fill every available hour with activities that might look good on a college application.

2. The Law of Focus: Go Deep Rather Than Broad

For years, students have been encouraged to become “well-rounded” applicants by participating in numerous unrelated activities.

Newport challenges this conventional wisdom.

Instead of joining six clubs and holding superficial leadership positions, students should consider investing substantial time in one or two interests they find genuinely engaging.

This doesn’t mean students must abandon other activities they enjoy. Rather, they should recognize that depth, sustained commitment, and meaningful accomplishments often tell a more compelling story than a lengthy list of memberships.

A student who spends years developing expertise in environmental conservation, for example, may demonstrate more initiative and intellectual curiosity than someone who joins multiple clubs primarily to fill an activities list.

In fact, some students would benefit from dropping some of their activities entering 11th grade and double down on their interests.

3. The Law of Innovation: Pursue Accomplishments That Are Hard to Explain, Not Hard to Do

Perhaps Newport’s most intriguing insight is that unusual accomplishments can be more compelling than conventional achievements that require enormous effort.

Consider two students.

One attends an expensive summer business program, earns a certificate, and adds another line to a resume.

The other becomes fascinated with a problem, develops an original solution, and creates something independently.

The second student’s accomplishment may not come with a prestigious institutional name attached. But it offers something more interesting: a story of curiosity, experimentation, and initiative.

These accomplishments are “hard to explain” because they don’t fit neatly into familiar extracurricular categories, not because they’re necessarily difficult or expensive to pursue.

What This Looks Like in Practice: Examples from Great College Advice Students

We’ve seen Newport’s philosophy come to life through students we’ve counseled.

One student with a genuine interest in health and fitness decided to build a fitness app. Rather than simply joining another club or attending a summer program, he transformed a personal interest into a tangible project.

Another student who loved nature started a terrarium business, turning his fascination with plants and natural environments into an entrepreneurial venture.

Neither activity followed a traditional college admissions playbook.

That’s precisely what makes them interesting.

These students pursued something that mattered to them, developed new skills, and took ownership of their projects. Their experiences also provided authentic material for college essays and admissions interviews.

Importantly, the value wasn’t simply that they created an app or launched a business. It was the process of turning curiosity into action.

Authenticity Is the Real Competitive Advantage

Selective colleges receive applications from thousands of academically accomplished students. Many have impressive grades, rigorous coursework, leadership titles, and extensive extracurricular activities.

What can distinguish an applicant is the ability to demonstrate genuine intellectual curiosity, independent thinking, personal growth, and meaningful engagement.

That doesn’t require founding a nonprofit, publishing research, or launching a business. A student might pursue an unusual artistic interest, become deeply involved in a local community issue, or develop expertise in a subject rarely explored in high school.

The possibilities are nearly endless.

The important thing is that the experience grows organically from the student’s interests rather than from a calculated attempt to impress an admissions committee.

Our Advice: Build an Interesting Life, Not Just an Impressive Resume

At Great College Advice, we encourage students to explore their interests, develop their strengths, and pursue opportunities that reflect who they are.

Our role isn’t to manufacture impressive extracurricular activities. It’s to help students recognize their interests, identify opportunities for meaningful growth, and develop the confidence to take initiative.

That’s why we continue to recommend How to Be a High School Superstar to students and parents.

More than 15 years after its publication, Newport’s message remains remarkably relevant: Don’t spend high school trying to become the applicant you think colleges want. Spend it becoming a more curious, capable, and interesting person.

The strongest college application may ultimately be a natural byproduct of a high school experience well lived.


How Great College Advice Can Help

At Great College Advice, our experienced college counselors help students discover their interests, pursue meaningful extracurricular opportunities, and develop authentic college applications that reflect their individual strengths. Rather than relying on formulaic resume-building strategies, we provide personalized guidance that empowers students to take initiative, grow intellectually, and find colleges where they can thrive.

Contact Great College Advice to schedule a complimentary consultation and learn how we can help your student make the most of their high school years.

Related Posts