Letters of recommendation (LORs) provide admissions officers with third-party insight into a student’s academic abilities, classroom engagement, and character — information that grades and test scores alone cannot reveal. At selective colleges, LORs can carry as much weight as essays or interviews, especially at smaller private institutions where admissions officers have time to read them carefully.
How do admissions committees evaluate these confidential communications? Read this guide that can help your family make strategic decisions about which teachers to ask, when to ask, and how to position your student for the strongest possible endorsements.
How much weight do selective colleges give to letters of recommendation compared to other application components?
The weight colleges assign to letters of recommendation varies significantly based on institution type and selectivity. Larger state universities typically rely more heavily on quantitative metrics (GPA, test scores, and class rank) because their admissions offices process enormous application volumes. However, as selectivity increases, the importance of recommendations rises dramatically.
”In general, the smaller a school, the more the essays and the letters of recommendation matter because the staff has more time to actually read them in depth. Big state universities are going to be more based on your data: your grades and your [test] scores. Honors colleges within those schools will read your essays more and read the letters [of recommendation] more carefully.”
— Jamie Berger, Veteran College Admissions Expert
For families targeting Ivy League and top 20 schools, this insight can change their entire strategy. These institutions perform “holistic” reviews where LORs can be as important as essays or interviews. Teachers have a clear view of the student’s ability and attitude in the classroom, and colleges genuinely want to learn from these observations. The recommendation provides context that transforms a transcript from a series of grades into a story about intellectual curiosity, resilience, and classroom presence.
For comprehensive guidance on all aspects of the application process, see our Top-Tier College Application Tips to Maximize Your Chances.
What specific information do admissions officers look for in teacher recommendations?
Letters of recommendation contain two components that admissions officers evaluate carefully.
- The first is a narrative account from the teacher’s perspective
This is a qualitative assessment that ideally includes specific examples of the student’s achievements, general abilities, and attitude in class. The best narratives move beyond generic praise to show how a student thinks, engages with challenges, and contributes to the learning environment.
- The second component is what Great College Advice calls the “Invisible Common App”
These are the elements that students never see but that significantly influence admissions decisions. Teachers complete a rating grid with fourteen separate criteria, comparing the student not only to their current peer group but to all students the teacher has ever encountered. Counselors complete a separate evaluation with three criteria, assessing the student within the broader school context.
The Invisible Common App: Beyond the narrative, teachers rate students on fourteen different criteria using checkboxes. These comparative ratings provide admissions officers with standardized data points across all applicants, revealing where a student truly stands against years of the teacher’s experience.
When written carefully, these recommendations paint a vivid picture of academic performance and potential. A teacher who can describe a student’s intellectual growth, participation quality, and genuine engagement provides far more valuable insight than one who simply confirms good grades.
Can a negative or lukewarm letter of recommendation hurt my student’s chances at competitive schools?
Absolutely, and this risk extends even to schools that don’t read recommendations extensively. The impact of a negative or ambivalent letter cannot be overstated.
“What’s important is that even the big schools that don’t read them that carefully, a negative letter they will notice, or a letter that hints at negativity, they will notice. So keep that in mind when you’re meeting those junior year class teachers for the first time,” notes Jamie.
This is why relationship-building matters as much as academic performance. A student who earns an A but remains “a stone-faced stoic kid who never speaks in class” — or worse, displays subtle dismissiveness — won’t inspire a compelling recommendation. Teachers need to genuinely know and respect the students to write authentically about their potential.
If a teacher declines a recommendation request, consider it valuable information. That person likely would not have written a strong letter, and a lukewarm endorsement can be more damaging than a missing one. Students should work with their counselor to identify alternative recommenders who can speak genuinely to their strengths.
When should my student ask for letters of recommendation, and how should they approach teachers?
Strategic timing and approach can significantly influence the quality of recommendations your student receives. The foundation is laid throughout junior year, with the formal request made before the school year ends.
As Jamie often says, “Your letters of recommendation are generally expected to be from junior year teachers. Be an engaged, active, committed student in your junior year classes. Come early or stay late. Chat with your teacher, but not superficially — find out what really intrigues you and engage them. You’re going to need two teachers. Figure out who your favorite two teachers are and dig in deep.”
The most important tactics are asking early and asking in person. The spring of junior year is the optimal window before teachers leave for summer, and while your student’s performance is fresh in their minds. Waiting until the fall of senior year means competing with dozens of other requests when teachers are already overwhelmed.
Best Practice Timeline:
- Junior Year: Build genuine relationships with teachers; engage authentically in class discussions
- Spring of Junior Year: Request recommendations in person, before the school year ends
- One Month Before Deadlines: Remind teachers of upcoming due dates
- After Submission: Send handwritten thank-you notes; update teachers upon college acceptance
Students should also prepare a “brag sheet,” a document containing facts about their activities, achievements, and goals that helps teachers write more detailed, specific letters. Many schools provide templates, but even a simple summary of accomplishments can help a teacher craft a more compelling narrative.
Should my student get a letter from a VIP, prestigious alumnus, or elected official?
In most cases, VIP recommendations backfire rather than help. Padding applications with impressive-sounding names signals a lack of substance rather than genuine qualification.
Unless a VIP knows your student genuinely well — meaning they can speak specifically to the student’s character, intellectual curiosity, and potential — such letters add nothing meaningful. Admissions officers immediately distinguish between authentic relationships and transparent name-drops. A senator who met your student once at a fundraiser cannot provide the insight that a teacher who watched your student grapple with challenging material for an entire year can offer.
In very specific instances, a VIP letter might help — for example, if a respected alumnus has mentored your student through a substantial research project or extracurricular endeavor. But families should consult with their counselor before pursuing this route. The bar for “knowing the student well” is high, and misreading this can make an application appear calculated rather than genuine.
Should my student waive their right to see their letters of recommendation?
Yes, your student should always waive this right. Colleges regard waived letters with significantly more credibility because they represent unfiltered, confidential assessments. When admissions officers know a student has potentially seen and approved a letter, they discount its authenticity.
The waiver signals confidence and maturity. It demonstrates that your student trusts their recommenders and has nothing to hide. Students who don’t waive their rights inadvertently suggest they’re managing their application image rather than presenting their genuine selves.
Occasionally, teachers or counselors will share letters after all applications have been submitted. If this happens, the information can be valuable for understanding how your student is perceived. But students should never request to see letters. The confidential nature of these communications is precisely what gives recommendations their weight in the evaluation process.
What’s the difference between counselor recommendations and teacher recommendations, and what if my counselor doesn’t know my student well?
Counselor and teacher recommendations serve distinct purposes in the application. Counselor recommendations give admissions officers a picture of the student within the entire school environment — academic standing, involvement in the school community, awards, and leadership. Teacher recommendations focus specifically on academic capabilities and classroom performance. Together, they create a three-dimensional portrait that transcripts alone cannot provide.
In large public high schools where counseling staff have been dramatically reduced, counselors may not know students individually. This is an increasingly common challenge that admissions officers understand. In worst-case scenarios, counselors may indicate on the form that they have no basis to judge a student, and selective schools will not hold this against applicants from schools where it’s the norm.
However, families can take proactive steps to strengthen the counselor recommendation:
Strategies for Large Schools:
- Connect with the counselor as early and often as possible, regardless of where you are in the process
- Complete parent questionnaires thoroughly — counselors often draw directly from these narratives
- Attend school college planning meetings when invited
- Provide the counselor with a “brag sheet” containing achievements and context they may not know
- Explore alternative ways to ensure admissions offices receive the supporting information they need
The goal is to give the counselor enough material to write a compelling letter even without extensive personal interaction. The stories and comments parents provide in questionnaires often become the backbone of the counselor’s recommendation.
Ready to Maximize Your Application Strategy?
Letters of recommendation are just one element of a successful college application. At Great College Advice, we help ambitious families navigate every aspect of the admissions process — from strategic teacher selection to essay development to building a balanced college list.
Book a consultation to get personalized 1:1 college guidance.
