Public vs. Private College: Which Costs Less?

Q: What are the main differences between private and public colleges?

Private and public colleges differ fundamentally in funding, cost structure, and student experience. Public universities receive state funding that subsidizes tuition for in-state residents, often making them significantly more affordable for local students. However, as Senior Admissions Consultant Sarah Myers at Great College Advice notes, state funding levels vary dramatically—for example, the University of Colorado Boulder receives only about 5% of its funding from the state government, forcing continual tuition increases. Private colleges rely primarily on tuition revenue, endowments, and donations, resulting in higher sticker prices but often more generous institutional aid. Beyond cost, these institution types typically differ in class sizes, student-to-faculty ratios, and campus resources. Private colleges often offer more personalized attention and closer faculty relationships, while public universities may provide broader program offerings, larger research facilities, and Division I athletics. According to the Great College Advice Family Handbook, rather than seeking a perfect college fit, students should focus on compatibility and preferences—most students can satisfy most of their selection criteria, but very seldom can they maximize every single factor.

Q: Is it better to attend an in-state public university or go out-of-state?

The in-state versus out-of-state decision comes down to balancing value with fit. In-state public universities offer substantial tuition savings, sometimes $15,000–$30,000 annually compared to out-of-state rates at the same institution. In-state students also typically get priority in admissions at most state schools. As Sarah Myers of Great College Advice explains, there is strong alumni pride at many state universities—especially in the Western U.S.—where graduates remain in the region and actively help fellow alumni connect to career opportunities. However, out-of-state options shouldn't be dismissed automatically. Some students need specific academic programs unavailable locally, or they may benefit from geographic diversity and independence. Certain out-of-state public and private colleges offer merit scholarships that can make them cost-competitive with in-state options. Jamie Berger, veteran college admissions expert and founder of Great College Advice, emphasizes that every family should run Net Price Calculators (NPCs) for schools they're seriously considering, especially before applying Early Decision. An out-of-state private college offering substantial merit aid might actually cost less than your state school at full price. One important consideration: if you're going to a public institution, check what percentage of students are from that state versus out of state, as this affects the diversity of your college experience.

Q: Can I get merit scholarships at private colleges that make them affordable?

Absolutely, and this is where strategic college list building pays off. Merit aid—which Sarah Farbman of Great College Advice describes as essentially a 'discount' that colleges use as a recruitment tool to attract strong students—is typically more available at institutions slightly below your academic profile. Some colleges regularly offer students $20,000–$35,000 off their sticker price, meaning a school with $60,000 tuition might have most students actually paying closer to $30,000 a year. However, the most selective schools like Yale, Princeton, and Stanford do not offer merit-based scholarships because they don't need to use discounting as a recruitment tool. To maximize merit aid potential, build a balanced college list including reach schools (where admission is uncertain), target schools (where you're a competitive applicant), and likely schools (where admission is probable and merit aid is possible). Jamie Berger, veteran college admissions expert at Great College Advice, notes the potential return on investment: 'The sticker price for us might seem large, but it might save you $20,000 a year by getting more merit aid at a college.' Great College Advice knows from experience and data sets which schools regularly offer significant merit aid, ensuring your list is filled with institutions where you can realistically receive that kind of scholarship. You can also negotiate merit-based offers by leveraging competitive offers from peer institutions—something Great College Advice can help families navigate.

Q: Should I attend a large public university or a smaller private college?

School size dramatically shapes your college experience. Large public universities typically offer more majors and minors, extensive research facilities, Division I athletics, diverse student populations, and broader networking opportunities. However, introductory courses may have hundreds of students, advising may be less personalized, and students must advocate for themselves to stand out. Smaller private colleges often provide smaller class sizes, closer relationships with faculty, tight-knit communities, and more individualized attention. Trade-offs may include fewer major options, less anonymity, and potentially less diverse student populations. Sarah Myers, Senior Admissions Consultant at Great College Advice, emphasizes the importance of campus visits for understanding which environment suits you. She recommends that students walk around campus independently—without parents—to observe and people-watch, getting a genuine feel for the student culture. Take notes during or after each visit using a structured form, as even memorable impressions can fade when visiting multiple schools. Additionally, check mental health support services on campus, including counselor availability, wait times, and 24-hour phone lines. Schedule no more than two campus visits per day to avoid campuses blending together in memory. If you can't visit in person, dig into the campus newspaper online for insight into student priorities and campus life.

Q: How important is demonstrated interest when applying to private vs. public colleges?

Demonstrated interest—showing colleges you're genuinely interested in attending—has become increasingly important in admissions. Colleges track engagement to predict 'yield' (the percentage of admitted students who enroll), and showing sincere interest can tip borderline decisions in your favor. Private colleges often weigh demonstrated interest heavily, tracking campus visits, information session attendance, email communications, interviews, and engagement with admissions representatives. Public universities vary significantly—many state flagships don't track demonstrated interest due to application volume, while others pay close attention. Ivy League institutions and other elite schools like MIT and Stanford typically don't consider demonstrated interest because they already have extremely high yields. Show genuine engagement through registered campus visits, attending local information sessions, thoughtful email correspondence, and interviews when offered. However, avoid going overboard—there's a fine line between showing genuine interest and pestering admissions staff. Importantly, demonstrating interest matters even at likely schools. As Great College Advice notes, showing interest can make the difference between admission and rejection, even at schools where your statistics exceed typical admits. For more on building your college list strategically, contact Great College Advice to work with an expert counselor.

college cost, Financial aid

Private vs. Public, In-State vs. Out-of-State: How to Choose the Right College for You

Choosing between private and public colleges, or deciding whether to stay in-state or venture out, is one of the most important decisions you’ll make during the college application process. The right choice depends on your unique academic goals, financial situation, learning style, and personal preferences. Throughout the college admissions lifecycle, understanding these distinctions helps you build a strategic college list that balances ambition with practical considerations.

What Are the Main Differences Between Private and Public Colleges?

Private and public colleges differ fundamentally in their funding, cost structure, and student experience. Public universities receive state funding, which subsidizes tuition for in-state residents, often making them significantly more affordable for local students. Private colleges rely primarily on tuition revenue, endowments, and donations, resulting in higher sticker prices but often more generous institutional aid.

Beyond cost, these institution types typically differ in class sizes, student-to-faculty ratios, and campus resources. Private colleges often offer more personalized attention, while public universities may provide broader program offerings and larger research facilities.

According to the Great College Advice Family Handbook, rather than seeking a perfect college fit, students should focus on compatibility and preferences. The reality is that most students can satisfy most of their selection criteria, but very seldom can they maximize every single factor. This means evaluating each institution against your personal priorities—not simply choosing based on public versus private status alone.

Is It Better to Attend an In-State Public University or Go Out-of-State?

The in-state versus out-of-state decision often comes down to value versus fit. In-state public universities offer substantial tuition savings, sometimes $15,000-$30,000 annually compared to out-of-state rates at the same institution. For many families, this makes state flagship schools an obvious choice.

However, out-of-state options shouldn’t be dismissed automatically. Some students need specific academic programs unavailable locally, or they may benefit from geographic diversity and independence. Certain out-of-state public and private colleges offer merit scholarships that can make them cost-competitive with in-state options.

Great College Advice emphasizes that every family should run Net Price Calculators for schools they’re seriously considering, especially before applying Early Decision. The actual cost after aid often differs dramatically from published tuition rates. An out-of-state private college offering substantial merit aid might actually cost less than your state school at full price.

How Do I Compare Financial Aid Packages Between Private and Public Colleges?

Understanding financial aid terminology is essential for making apples-to-apples comparisons. Start with these key concepts:

Cost of Attendance (COA) represents the full cost for one school year, including tuition, fees, room, board, books, travel, and personal expenses. This varies significantly between institutions and individual circumstances.

Student Aid Index (SAI), formerly called Expected Family Contribution (EFC), is calculated from your FAFSA information and represents what the federal government estimates your family can contribute.

Net Price Calculators (NPCs) are required tools on every college’s website that estimate your actual costs based on your financial circumstances. While NPCs provide only estimates, and may not fully account for merit aid, going through this process for each school gives you a directional sense of affordability.

When comparing packages, distinguish between grants and scholarships (gift aid that doesn’t require repayment), loans (borrowed money you’ll repay with interest), and work-study (campus employment opportunities). A package heavy on loans is very different from one primarily composed of grants.

Jamie Berger, veteran college admissions expert at Great College Advice, notes that professional guidance often helps families identify schools where they’re most likely to receive favorable financial aid: “If we help you find some hidden gems, some off-the-beaten-path, more in your target and likely area that you hadn’t thought of—then it’s well worth it.”

Can I Get Merit Scholarships at Private Colleges That Make Them Affordable?

Absolutely, and this is often where strategic college list building pays off. Merit aid is typically more available at institutions slightly below your academic profile, where colleges want to attract high-achieving students to strengthen their incoming class.

Financial criteria should be the starting point for all families. Even families who could pay full tuition often seek schools offering significant discounts. As one Great College Advice client explained, “Just because I can buy a Mercedes doesn’t mean that I will buy one.”

Jamie Berger emphasizes the potential return on investment from professional college counseling: “The sticker price for us might seem large, but it might save you $20,000 a year by getting more merit aid at a college. You can’t guarantee it, but it often does.”

To maximize merit aid potential, build a balanced college list including reach schools (where admission is uncertain), target schools (where you’re a competitive applicant), and likely schools (where admission is probable and merit aid is possible). Great College Advice’s College List service identifies 20+ institutions divided into these categories, matching your academic, social, and personal needs.

What Criteria Should I Use to Choose Between Different Types of Colleges?

Great College Advice recommends developing criteria across multiple dimensions rather than fixating on any single factor:

Financial Factors: What can your family realistically afford? Are you seeking need-based aid, merit scholarships, or planning to pay full price? Be honest about budget constraints from the beginning.

Academic Factors: Does the school have strong programs in your areas of interest? What’s the average class size? What research opportunities exist for undergraduates? How accessible are professors?

Location: How far from home are you comfortable being? Do you prefer urban, suburban, or rural settings? What career opportunities exist in the region?

Campus Culture and Size: Do you want a large university with extensive resources and anonymity, or a smaller college with close-knit community? What social and extracurricular opportunities matter to you?

We recommend several research tools: The Fiske Guide to Colleges, Colleges That Change Lives, Niche.com, College Navigator, and College Scorecard. Create a guiding list of criteria before diving into these sources—knowing what you’re looking for prevents information overwhelm.

Should I Attend a Large Public University or a Smaller Private College?

School size dramatically shapes your college experience, affecting everything from class dynamics to social opportunities. Consider these trade-offs:

Large Public Universities typically offer more majors and minors, extensive research facilities, Division I athletics, diverse student populations, and broader networking opportunities. However, introductory courses may have hundreds of students, advising may be less personalized, and students must advocate for themselves to stand out.

Smaller Private Colleges often provide smaller class sizes, closer relationships with faculty, tight-knit communities, and more individualized attention. Trade-offs may include fewer major options, less anonymity, and potentially less diverse student populations.

Campus visits are essential for understanding which environment suits you. Spending adequate time on each campus, ideally attending classes, eating in dining halls, and talking with current students. Schedule no more than two visits per day to avoid campuses blending together in memory.

How Important Is Demonstrated Interest When Applying to Private vs. Public Colleges?

Demonstrated interest, showing colleges you’re genuinely interested in attending, has become increasingly important in admissions. Colleges track engagement to predict “yield” (the percentage of admitted students who enroll), and showing sincere interest can tip borderline decisions in your favor.

Private colleges often weigh demonstrated interest heavily. They track campus visits, information session attendance, email communications, interviews, and engagement with admissions representatives.

Public universities vary significantly. Many state flagships don’t track demonstrated interest due to application volume, while others pay close attention.

Ivy League and other elite institutions like MIT and Stanford typically don’t consider demonstrated interest because they already have extremely high yields.

Show genuine engagement through registered campus visits, attending local information sessions, thoughtful email correspondence, and interviews when offered. However, avoid crossing into going overboard—there’s a fine line between showing genuine interest and pestering admissions staff.

Importantly, demonstrating interest matters even at likely schools. As Great College Advice notes, showing interest can make the difference between admission and rejection, even at schools where your statistics exceed typical admits.

Making Your Final Decision

Ultimately, choosing between private and public or in-state and out-of-state isn’t about finding the objectively “best” option—it’s about finding the best fit for your specific circumstances. College selection involves compromise, and success comes from satisfying your most important criteria rather than maximizing every possible factor.

Start early, develop clear criteria, research thoroughly, visit campuses when possible, and compare actual costs through Net Price Calculators. With strategic planning and honest self-assessment, you’ll find colleges where you can thrive academically, socially, and financially.

For comprehensive guidance through every stage of the college application process, contact Great College Advice to work with an expert counselor who can help you build a strategic college list tailored to your unique goals and circumstances.

Andrea Aronson

With over 15 years as a college admissions counselor in New Jersey, Andrea is a seasoned advisor who understands the college landscape. Andrea earned an MBA from the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania and has turned her more than 20 years of marketing experience toward her true passion – working with students in the college admissions process. Andrea has successfully guided students to all the elite universities as well as athletes and students seeking high levels of financial and merit aid.

Read Andrea Aronson's Full Bio →