Comparing GPAs at Between High Schools

A prospective client asked me a question this morning about comparing GPAs across high schools.  He asked how college admissions officers compare a the GPA of a student at  very low performing high school with a very high performing high school.

We didn’t get into a discussion about how one really measures high vs. low performance at different high schools. But our assumption seemed to be related to performance on state tests mandated by No Child Left Behind.

The answer to the question is “it depends.” If we are talking about a public institution, then depending on the state, the context of a students’ GPA gets very little attention.  So for some state institutions it may make no difference in the admissions process whether a student was in a high or low performing school. Keep in mind, however, that not all state-financed institutions are the same (admissions standards and practices at William and Mary are very different from those at Christopher Newport, for example).

How Do Colleges Compare GPAs?

However, when a college or university has a “holistic” admissions process, they will look at the student in the context of where that student went to school.  Admissions staff will take into account the strength of the student’s curriculum, the profile of the school that he attended (the percentage of students attend college, for example), and other tangibles and intangibles.

Admissions is not a scientific process.  I try to counsel my clients to stay focused on getting a good education. Learn as much as possible, and find subjects and ideas that excite them.  If a student can dwell on the learning and not the GPA, everything else will fall into place.

Mark Montgomery
Educational Consultant

To learn more about our advising services, complete our contact form or call us at 720.279.7577.

Want to stay informed about college admission trends? Want to be able to ask questions of experts who can give you some Great College Advice?

Join our Facebook group today.

Great College Advice offers college admissions advice to high school students and their families around the country and around the world. We help students look differently at college admissions and navigate the changing educational landscape. We give our students a positive and insightful college planning experience with long-lasting effects. Because it’s not just about college—it’s about your life’s journey.

Technorati Tags: GPA, high school, college, university, admission, application Tags: GPA, high school, college, university, admission, application

Published by Mark Montgomery

Mark is a leading educational consultant. His experience as a professor, college administrator, and youth mentor help him guide students from around the country and around the world.

Join the Conversation


  1. Dr. Montgomery,
    A HS student can get GPA 4.0 easy in a very low performing HS, but for 3.5 is very hard for him in a very high permorming HS. So I think this number which is not fair for applying to college, but SAT/ACT score should be reasonable. Please tell me your idea. Thanks!

  2. Charles,

    Most colleges will look at the challenge of your high school curriculum, in addition to the competitiveness of your high school when reviewing your GPA. They determine how competitive your high school is by looking at the high school profile, which you school should provide each college with your application. The profile indicates how many students in your high school attend 4-year colleges and the average SAT of the previous class. So, you are correct that a straight GPA is no an accurate reflection of academic achievement. Any college that does a holistic application review process will look at all of the pieces of the puzzle. Please let us know if you have any other questions!

    Sincerely, Katherine Price
    Senior Associate

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Are you worried about

Are you confused about what your GPA says about you as a high school student?

  • What does your GPA really mean?
  • How do you calculate your GPA?
  • What is your "REAL" GPA?
  • How do colleges use the GPA in admission?
Get Your FREE GPA E-Book

Get ALL the answers to your questions about your GPA, and what it means for college admission.

Your GPA Mysteries Are Now Solved!